• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick couchmanrick@gmail.com

Oilers @ Leafs - Dec. 13th, 7:00pm - SN

OldTimeHockey said:
Do I want Matthews on my team?? Of course. Do I think he's a leader. Not in the least.

So I guess my point is that if Matthews is the closest thing to Gilmour, we're in trouble. Because I don't consider him remotely the same type of player. Gilmour bled for every team he played for. Matthews, as talented as he is, simply does not bring that attitude to the rink.
Click to expand...
I absolutely agree with your first statement.

But personally, I never thought Matthews skill set matches gilmour from a talent perspective, if anything Marner is the closest I've seen as a match talent wise.

As a leader though, you are correct, neither comes close.

My favourite all time player is Sundin, but I was nuts for Gilmour during those runs. But since those 2 eras, I have not seen a leafs player that rose to the occasion. Not even 1 fluke a la McCauley playoff run.

No Wendel, no Gilmour, no andreychuk, no Sundin, no Thomas, no tucker, no mogilny, no Roberts... How can they not had just one, just one player that can have a monster playoff. It's just crazy. I guess the closest is Nylander but he's not really doing more than what he does in the regular season.

Anyway I feel like I'm just ranting now.
 
OldTimeHockey said:
I'm not taking away from Matthews. Gap may not be the right word if we're looking at talent. But I'd take Gilmour leading this team any day of the week over Auston Matthews. Do I want Matthews on my team?? Of course. Do I think he's a leader. Not in the least.

So I guess my point is that if Matthews is the closest thing to Gilmour, we're in trouble. Because I don't consider him remotely the same type of player. Gilmour bled for every team he played for. Matthews, as talented as he is, simply does not bring that attitude to the rink.
Click to expand...
There seems to be a bit of a trend in hockey these days of just making your "best" player captain when often someone who isn't the best player might have more of the traits you want in a leader other than just being really, really, really good at hockey.

Looking at the Leafs roster, it's actually quite difficult to pick out a captain. Tavares as an elder statesman, proper pro who leads by example in terms of preparation and all that. He probably shouldn't have lost thee role. In fact, his grace in how he reacted when he did probably shows why he should have kept the role.

Tanev would be the kind of character I'd like as a captain, but obviously he's older, and potentially getting into going to miss a lot of time to injuries stage of his career and wouldn't be a longer term option.

If you were looking a "long term" option, I'd be intrigued by Knies potential to do it.

Actually looking at the roster from that point of view might suggest why the Leafs are where they are. It's a "weak" roster overall in terms of character/grittiness.
 
Joe S. said:
I absolutely agree with your first statement.

But personally, I never thought Matthews skill set matches gilmour from a talent perspective, if anything Marner is the closest I've seen as a match talent wise.

As a leader though, you are correct, neither comes close.

My favourite all time player is Sundin, but I was nuts for Gilmour during those runs. But since those 2 eras, I have not seen a leafs player that rose to the occasion. Not even 1 fluke a la McCauley playoff run.

No Wendel, no Gilmour, no andreychuk, no Sundin, no Thomas, no tucker, no mogilny, no Roberts... How can they not had just one, just one player that can have a monster playoff. It's just crazy. I guess the closest is Nylander but he's not really doing more than what he does in the regular season.

Anyway I feel like I'm just ranting now.
Click to expand...
I replied to OTH's post before I saw this one. I think we maybe agree and are surmising similar things.

Interestingly some of the best "characters" willing to put the team on their back of late have been goalies - thinking of CuJo and Belfour.

I agree fully on your point about the skaters.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top