Zanzibar Buck-Buck McFate said:
I must say, whatever "jolt effect" McMann has brought to the fourth line has faded. I don't think he's been better than Reaves.
I made a point of saying multiple times that it felt like a Reaves-4th line was basically playing short handed because Reaves was basically behind the play and a non-factor in every play 95% of the time he stepped on the ice. I wouldn't exactly use that description with McMann. You can see him actually playing plays here and there, but yes the 4th line is still very much an issue:
Gregor-Kampf-Reaves: 45.03 CF%, 1.69 GF/60, 6.77 GA/60, 20.00 GF%, 38.21 xGF%
Gregor-Kampf-McMann: 44.12 CF%, 1.66 GF/60, 3.31 GA/60, 33.33 GF%, 39.58 xGF%
It's worth noting that the McMann-results come with the line playing tougher minutes: a 23.81% offensive-zone face off percentage vs. 44.44% with Reaves on it. But again yes those results are pretty unacceptable and while I like McMann as a player and think he's capable of better than this if the results don't change on the ice soon he needs to be replaced. Not sure anyone on the Marlies like Holmberg or Steeves would drastically change what's going on there though.
edit: I also don't necessarily think that McMann is the only problem there. Kampf and Gregor both deserve a share of the blame too, but it's obviously very unlikely all 3 players get changed.