LeafsInSeven said:
The Leafs set the price in the late winter giving $3.875m per season. Calgary decided to pay an indistinguishable defenseman from Liles over $1M more per season.
I don't think it's fair to say Wideman is indistinguishable from Liles. There seems to be two pretty significant differences in Wideman's favour. The first is that Wideman is two and a half years younger, so his deal covers years 28-33. Liles' deal covers years 32-36.
The other is that Wideman seems to be regarded as a more well rounded defenseman. He's gotten regular and significant PK time over the last five seasons and, as a result, his ice time over those years has ranged from 23:33 all the way up to 25:09. Liles has never really gotten a look on the PK and his ice time has ranged from 18:28 to to 22:01.
I don't know if 1.4 million covers both of those differences but I'd probably say that both deals are equally questionable.