• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick couchmanrick@gmail.com

Blue Jays Hot Stove Thread

The free agent class next year is Robbie Ray, James Paxton and Trevor Bauer (and Stroman).

I?m not really seeing the big upside to waiting for next years crop unless the hope is that the insane prices revert back next offseason. 
 
L K said:
The free agent class next year is Robbie Ray, James Paxton and Trevor Bauer (and Stroman).

I?m not really seeing the big upside to waiting for next years crop unless the hope is that the insane prices revert back next offseason.

I think it's less about there being a huge upside and more about being unsure about Ryu who, although he had a big year, doesn't have a history of consistency or durability.
 
L K said:
The free agent class next year is Robbie Ray, James Paxton and Trevor Bauer (and Stroman).

I?m not really seeing the big upside to waiting for next years crop unless the hope is that the insane prices revert back next offseason.

It's what happens when you run the team into the ground and now they can't get players to come here.  There was no reason to trade Stroman - he could have anchored this rotation for the next few seasons. 
 
Nik Bethune said:
L K said:
The free agent class next year is Robbie Ray, James Paxton and Trevor Bauer (and Stroman).

I?m not really seeing the big upside to waiting for next years crop unless the hope is that the insane prices revert back next offseason.

I think it's less about there being a huge upside and more about being unsure about Ryu who, although he had a big year, doesn't have a history of consistency or durability.

Consistency is going to be an issue with the top free agent class next year too.  You also aren?t signing Ray or Bauer for 80 million
 
L K said:
Consistency is going to be an issue with the top free agent class next year too.  You also aren?t signing Ray or Bauer for 80 million

Well, the way I heard it is that the real question in some people's minds is Paxton vs. Ryu. Honestly, at the free agent prices going around, I don't really like any of those guys.
 
Jays go dumpster diving to get a new 1B.  Travis Shaw who had two good years in SAN Diego and then was abysmal last year.
 
L K said:
Jays go dumpster diving to get a new 1B.  Travis Shaw who had two good years in SAN Diego and then was abysmal last year.

Hoping Shaw is more of a utility infield type.  He's played more third than first, and has also played second in his career.  It's a dumpster dive for sure, but the guy drove in 100+ two years ago.  It could be a good find if it works out. 

My biggest concern is that this is in fact the first base platoon with Telez and that they're not going to sign EE.  If that's the case, I'm pissed.  As a utility infielder, I'm good with this move.
 
Shaw is a a weird case, projections willbe near impossible. One thing is sure, he must hit or its yet another shitty signing.
 
Well, I'm not huge on this because of the risk factors but this should at least close off some of the "The Jays can't sign anyone" talk.
 
Nik Bethune said:
Well, I'm not huge on this because of the risk factors but this should at least close off some of the "The Jays can't sign anyone" talk.

I?m not a big fan of the signing either but I like it because it will shut up the people who say that this front office won?t or can?t sign a significant free agent
.
 
I like it but have to ask did they change course?  I mean what happened to the slow and patient re-build they keep preaching. Honestly, as the 3rd largest city in NA we should be trying to win the WS every single season.
 
The Empire said:
I like it but have to ask did they change course?  I mean what happened to the slow and patient re-build they keep preaching. Honestly, as the 3rd largest city in NA we should be trying to win the WS every single season.

The teams that have actually won things in recent years are teams that have done so with players they develop themselves. "Trying to win" by spending like drunken sailors every winter might make fans feel better but there's no real case that it actually involves any actual championships.

 
Ryu is a fastball master and is in command of his pitches.
?Control? means where the pitch (ball) is supposed to go in the zone but ?Command? means where you want your pitch (ball) to be.  Two different things yet similar. 

Name                Team          Zero-K FB%        swSTR              Command+
Hyun-Jin Ryu    Dodgers          48.4%            11.5%                112
Marco Gonzales Mariners        34.5%              8.4%                    111
Kyle Gibson      Twins              52.1%              13.5%                  110
Noah Syndergaard Mets          58.9%              11.7%     
            107
Tanner Roark    Reds              53.1%              8.8%                    106
Merrill Kelly      D-backs          49.6%              8.9%                    106
Cole Hamels    Cubs           
54.9%              11.1%                    104
Ivan Nova        White Sox      54.3%              8.5%                    102
Rick Porcello    Red Sox        58.1%              7.6%                 
  102
Jake Odorizzi    Twins              58.8%            12.7%                    101
Mike Fiers     
Athletics          50.7%              7.2%                      99
Trevor Cahill    Angels            40.2%              9.4%                      98


[tweet]1208974283252236288[/tweet]
 
A healthy Ryu would be a true #1 starter, which would be huge - and, at a relative bargain compared to what other top flight pitchers have signed for. Obviously, health and age are a concern, but, he's not a power pitcher, so, as long as he can stay healthy, I'm not super worried about the aging curve.
 
Nik Bethune said:
The Empire said:
I like it but have to ask did they change course?  I mean what happened to the slow and patient re-build they keep preaching. Honestly, as the 3rd largest city in NA we should be trying to win the WS every single season.

The teams that have actually won things in recent years are teams that have done so with players they develop themselves. "Trying to win" by spending like drunken sailors every winter might make fans feel better but there's no real case that it actually involves any actual championships.

I disagree with this.  The successful teams need to be active on 4 fronts:
First Year Player Draft
International signings
Trades
Free Agent signings

Atkins and company have mentioned the Astros as a team they would like to model themselves on and as one that was built through the draft.  While they have done well drafting, by being active in free agency and trades is what got them to where they are now.

Drafted
Altuve
Springer
Correa
Bregman

International amateur signings
Alvarez
Gurriel

Mostly of the other impact players were obtained via trade or FA signings.
Verlander
Cole
Greinke
Osuna
 
All of the guys you list as impact guys they got via trade and free agency(and none were free agents, they were all traded for) were guys they got after they had rebuilt themselves internally. Nobody is saying you never make trades or add free agents just that you first need to draft guys like Correa and Bregman which you can't do unless you rebuild and are bad for a while.

Because, aside from everything else, you need to build up your system so that you're able to put the pieces in a trade that land you guys like Cole/Verlander/Greinke.
 
Back
Top