It's also interesting that Dubas got the job of president in Pittsburgh and not just GM. Something he was likely shooting for in Toronto. Hence the sudden departure and firing by Shanny.
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.Show posts Menu
Quote from: Bill33 on May 29, 2023, 11:02:26 AMMarner took enough grief from his last contract that out of all of them, I could see him signing a team friendly (er) deal. He won't be easy to replace- the leafs record with him out of the lineup is worse that any of the top 4.
Nylander goes through very uninspired stretches, especially defensively.
I could see Nylander wanting to cash in hard on his last season results. I say he's the one the leafs should jettison for balance. Target a true 1st pairing defenseman.
Quote from: bustaheims on May 26, 2023, 09:12:47 AMTreliving really does seem like a pretty run-of-the-mill GM type - he'll do some good, some bad, and a lot in between. He won't likely screw things up terribly, but he also won't likely improve them significantly. If the team is just looking for someone as a steward, he's fine. But, teams are typically looking for more than that.The word 'stewart' doesn't sit well with me, unless you also include the word 'placeholder' in reference to Treliving. Maybe (if he's the best of few options) sign him to a 1-2 year contract until better options become available.
Also, when it comes to looking at a GM's drafting record, anything past the 1st round is probably giving them too much credit. From the 2nd round on, it's typically the head of the scouting staff making the determinations on who to draft. The GM will often set parameters or identify certain traits they want to prioritize, but they're rarely making the decisions on the names being called.
Quote from: herman on May 26, 2023, 08:20:23 AMhttps://mapleleafshotstove.com/2023/05/26/evaluating-brad-trelivings-candidacy-for-maple-leafs-gm/
At least he has the same glasses
Quote from: bustaheims on May 24, 2023, 11:02:05 AMQuote from: Omallley on May 24, 2023, 10:24:14 AMJust to echo this - having a drop dead date, and planning for the worst are two things that seem like huge gaps here. It's management 101 regardless of your industry. Shanahan lost all control of the situation without those things in place - and unless there's way more to the story than we're being told in terms of how far down the road they are in a GM search, I'd have some serious concerns about Shanahan's "plan" if I were his boss.
As a fan, it feels like we're back in sideshow land without a competent person at the wheel.
Is this really all that different from any team firing their GM, other than the fact the Leafs were hoping to bring Dubas back? I have to imagine they approached this from a similar fashion as they would hiring a new GM - identify their top choices and go from there. Dubas was their top choice, but, obviously, that didn't work out, so they need to move on to the rest of the list. The only real difference here is that they have to conduct interviews after missing out on their top choice instead of conducting them all before making a decision - but, that's par for the course when you're hoping to extend an existing employee.
I can't imagine a scenario where Shanahan and the board didn't have a backup plan in place. They were clearly hoping they wouldn't have to execute it, but I'm confident it was there.
Honestly, I don't get the handwringing about all of this. Yes, things haven't played out how many of us would have liked them to, but the jump to suddenly the team doesn't have competent leadership feels like a huge stretch and a surface level media narrative. Anyone who has been around the league (or any business) long enough would have contingency plans in place, and I'm sure Shanahan and MLSE do.
Quote from: herman on May 20, 2023, 02:00:09 PMAre these serious suggestions for the coach that not only helped cover up sexual abuse, but wrote a glowing reference for the perpetrator to go on and do it again to another kid?
Quote from: herman on May 20, 2023, 12:20:45 PMQuote from: Bender on May 20, 2023, 11:32:25 AMQuote from: CarltonTheBear on May 20, 2023, 07:12:22 AMNot giving autonomy to the future GM is going to cost us chances at the very best candidates. And I mean, it already has.
I agree, but already has meaning Dubas? It'll be hard to see a power struggle like this if Lou was in charge. I think the team needs an experienced GM who they feel like they don't have to watch so closely.
Which reads to me like, Shanahan kept the guy that wasn't a threat to him, until he became one.
Quote from: CarltonTheBear on May 19, 2023, 02:55:16 PMQuote from: L K on May 19, 2023, 02:50:34 PMTo be clear. Dubas absolutely plays a big part in this. That press conference was truly bizarre for a guy running an organization. I would have been looking at him as unreliable after that presser. But given that, the time to fire him was Tuesday not Friday
I don't have a problem with what he said on Monday. I can understand others thinking otherwise but that's just me. Having a framework for a new contract completed last weekend and then asking for a presumably hefty increase on Thursday is a pretty odd move on Dubas' part though (assuming that Shanny is being 100% truthful regarding that).
Page created in 0.063 seconds with 18 queries.