Matthews
HM...very tough, but I think I'll go with Engvall even though Spezza was a notch or two better than he usually is. I simply cannot go with Freddie when he spots them to a 1 goal lead, then was meh on the second goal, and had some shaky moments throughout the night. He was fabulous at times, too, and insane in OT, but I'd argue that the game should never have gotten there if he'd had a HM-worthy night.
Hope he has the flu: Tavares. That night was unacceptable for any player on the team, let alone its captain.