He's won everything he could as a team member. OHL, Memorial Cup, WJC, Canada/Wold Cup, World Championship, Olympic Gold, Stanley Cup. He was too good for the AHL. And he's won a Hart & Rocket Trophy along with multiple NHL All Star selections and a bundle of Junior awards. He's been to the Cup finals with four different teams. That's very likely to be a Hockey Hall of Fame resume if this incident in Chicago doesn't get in the way.
However, he's turning 39 in May (during the playoffs) - one of the oldest players in the league. If the Leafs won a Cup with Perry this spring, Perry would be the second oldest player in NHL history to win a Stanley Cup (according to one source - not sure if that is accurate but it is not far off) - which should give you a sense of how unlikely it is he'd be able to help.
He's a forward - they don't age as well in 2024 because they need to be able to skate with some speed.
NHL Edge shows his skating speed has really fallen off in the last two seasons.
His points have also been in decline.
Anaheim bought him out.
Dallas walked away after a year at $1.5 mil.
Montreal walked away after a year at $750k
Tampa walked away after 2 years at $1 mil in part because he was -28 on Tampa last season when the second worst was -9. That has to be a red flag.
He was a minus player all those seasons but one. Same for playoffs.
He did have a good six games against the Leafs in the playoffs last year. He seemed to perform better in the playoffs than the regular season.
Pavelski is the only 39 year old forward still performing well. His points production hasn't dipped much like Perry's has. His skating speed hasn't fallen as much. Pavelski is still performing as 2nd liner vs Perry being a 4th liner since 2018-19.
Perry has this dark cloud over him
?I have started working with experts in the mental health and substance abuse fields to discuss my struggles with alcohol, and I will take whatever steps necessary to ensure this never happens again,? Perry after Chicago incident in Dec 2023
He was never suspended by the league. The NHLPA may grieve his contract termination because they feel it fell short of historical justification to terminate. So whatever happened, it wasn't super serious.
He's a strong personality and they'd have to assess how he would fit into the room.
I've only seen Perry play the Leafs a few times in the last few years. Not enough to be very sure. I wouldn't say never at this point because of my ignorance - haven't seen him enough. A bunch of due diligence would have to get done.
Great career but I'm left with a bunch of trepidation for this season.