Masterton Trophy Finalists!

[Zee]

What the hell is Alfredsson nominated for--being old?

 

[Boston Leaf]

What the hell is Alfredsson nominated for--being old?

playing with dementia

 

[bustaheims]

Not trying to take anything away from Lupul or Alfie but I think MP's 32 goal season coming back off a broken vertebrae will probably land him the Masterton - in only his second season on top of that.

MaxPac had an impressive season, no doubt, but, in hindsight, his injuries weren't as severe as they sound. Lupul's injury/setbacks had him much closer to having his career over.

 

[Madferret]

What the hell is Alfredsson nominated for--being old?

And scoring more goals than Lupul

 

[Tigger]

What the hell is Alfredsson nominated for--being old?

And scoring more goals than Lupul

:

 

[CarltonTheBear]

Not trying to take anything away from Lupul or Alfie but I think MP's 32 goal season coming back off a broken vertebrae will probably land him the Masterton - in only his second season on top of that.

MaxPac had an impressive season, no doubt, but, in hindsight, his injuries weren't as severe as they sound. Lupul's injury/setbacks had him much closer to having his career over.

Wasn't it reported that Pac would have been able to rejoin the Habs if they made it further into the playoffs? I really don't see how missing a couple of months with a pretty bad injury trumps Lupul who could have easily been finished as a NHL player.

 

[Madferret]

Not trying to take anything away from Lupul or Alfie but I think MP's 32 goal season coming back off a broken vertebrae will probably land him the Masterton - in only his second season on top of that.

MaxPac had an impressive season, no doubt, but, in hindsight, his injuries weren't as severe as they sound. Lupul's injury/setbacks had him much closer to having his career over.

Wasn't it reported that Pac would have been able to rejoin the Habs if they made it further into the playoffs? I really don't see how missing a couple of months with a pretty bad injury trumps Lupul who could have easily been finished as a NHL player.

Just an opinion - not trying to depreciate what Lupul had to overcome.

 

[LittleHockeyFan]

What the hell is Alfredsson nominated for--being old?

pity vote cause he's never won anything?  (I don't know that, I'm just guessing)

 

[bustaheims]

Wasn't it reported that Pac would have been able to rejoin the Habs if they made it further into the playoffs? I really don't see how missing a couple of months with a pretty bad injury trumps Lupul who could have easily been finished as a NHL player.

On top of that, if Lupul doesn't hurt his shoulder late in the season, he probably cracks the 30 goal plateau as well. He basically had as good a season as Pacioretty, but came back from a more serious, (though, obviously, not as publicized) situation.

 

[Bender]

Wasn't it reported that Pac would have been able to rejoin the Habs if they made it further into the playoffs? I really don't see how missing a couple of months with a pretty bad injury trumps Lupul who could have easily been finished as a NHL player.

On top of that, if Lupul doesn't hurt his shoulder late in the season, he probably cracks the 30 goal plateau as well. He basically had as good a season as Pacioretty, but came back from a more serious, (though, obviously, not as publicized) situation.

Yeah. I feel like if MP wins it'll be partly because of the insane media frenzy Montreal kicked up. CHARA IS A CRIMINAL.